A consumption tax is a tax on the value of consumption just as an income tax is a tax on income.
So, if the value of consumption is GH¢100, you impose Covid levy (1% = 0.01), Getfund levy (2.5% = 0.025), NHIS levy (2.5% = 0.025), Tourism levy (1% = 0.01), and VAT (15% = 0.15) on GH¢100. You impose them separately on the value of consumption.
That is, in this example, the total consumption tax is 0.01*100 + 0.025*100 + 0.025*100 + 0.01*100 + 0.15*100 = (0.01 + 0.025 + 0.025 + 0.01 + 0.15)*100 = 0.22*100 = GH¢22 = 22% of GH¢100.
The sum of the levies (taxes) and VAT is 22%. So, you impose a total consumption tax of 22% on GH¢100 to get GH¢22 cedis.
Unfortunately, the Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA) has instructed businesses to compute the consumption tax differently.
In the example above, the sum of the levies is 7%. Under the GRA's method, this 7% is first applied to GH¢100 (the value of consumption) to get a consumption tax of GH¢7.
Then the GH¢7 is added to GH¢100 cedis to get a tax inclusive amount of GH¢107. Then the 15% VAT is imposed on the GH¢107 to get a consumption tax of 0.15*107 = GH¢16.05.
Thus, the total consumption tax is GH¢7 + GH¢16.05 = GH¢23.015.
The GRA's (and Ministry of Finance) incorrect calculation imposes a tax on a tax (i.e., the 15% VAT is imposed on the levy-inclusive value of consumption, which is GH¢107 in this example).
A levy is a tax!!! That is why levies require parliamentary approval. Even if parliamentary approval is not required, a levy is still a tax (with a different name).
The GRA's incorrect calculation increases the consumption tax rate from 22% to 23.05%. For large-value transactions and/or for transactions that involve millions of people, the 1.05 percentage point increase makes a big difference.
Look at the attached bill from Grillroom, a restaurant in Cantonments. The value of consumption (indicated as "bill amount") was 341.72 cedis.
Therefore, the total bill plus all the consumption taxes should have been 341.72 + 0.22*341.72 = 1.22*341.72 = 416.935 cedis.
But the bill (including consumption taxes) was 420 cedis which is equal to 341.72 + 0.2305*341.72 = 1.2305*341.72 cedis (this is actually equal to 420.48 cedis).
The VAT amount should have been 0.15*341.72 = 51.258 cedis. Instead, the VAT amount was 54.33 cedis. This was because the 15% VAT was imposed on the tax/levy-inclusive amount of 1.07*341.72 cedis to get 0.15*1.07*341.72, which is approximately equal to 54 cedis.
If the government wants to impose a consumption tax of 23.05%, why can't it do this in a transparent manner by asking parliament to increase one of the levies and/or VAT accordingly? Why does it use an incorrect and inconsistent method? Principles matter. Proper procedures matter.
In general, if L is the sum of levies and V is the VAT rate, the GRA's calculation increases the consumption tax by L*V (L times V). In the example above, V = 15% = 0.15 and L = 7% = 0.07. This gives L times V = 0.07 times 0.15 = 0.0105 = 1.05%, as obtained above.
Note: for some transactions (non-hospitality industry transactions), the 1% tourism is not applicable. This does not change the substantive point that consumption tax is incorrectly calculated in Ghana. It's a shame.
Source: graphiconline.com
Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are those of the writers and do not reflect those of Peacefmonline.com. Peacefmonline.com accepts no responsibility legal or otherwise for their accuracy of content. Please report any inappropriate content to us, and we will evaluate it as a matter of priority. |